We’ve all chased the next big thing in marketing — new channels, new tactics, new buzzwords. But artificial intelligence (AI) visibility is more than just another trend. It’s reshaping how everyone — from personal lines shoppers to business decision-makers — discovers and trusts insurance brands online.
Table of Contents
A new benchmark from Semrush, the 2025 AI Visibility Index, found that AI-driven search is already changing how brands get found. And those shifts matter more than most agencies, carriers, and MGAs realize.
What the Study Found About Visibility in AI Platforms
Semrush analyzed 2,500 real-world prompts across platforms like ChatGPT and Google’s AI search. Here are some key findings that stand out:
- Less than 20% of brands were both frequently mentioned and cited as sources — a gap Semrush calls the “Mention–Source Divide.”
- AI search is expected to surpass traditional search traffic by 2028.
- Brand reputation and public sentiment now influence how often AI tools recommend or cite you.
In short: AI models don’t just read your website. They evaluate who’s talking about you, how credible you sound, and whether others trust your content across the entire digital ecosystem.
Why AI Visibility Matters for Insurance
Insurance has always been built on trust and credibility — and that’s exactly what AI algorithms reward. Here’s why this shift hits close to home.
Everyone Is Asking AI
Whether it’s a homeowner asking, “Do I need flood insurance if I’m not in a flood zone?” or a business owner asking, “What’s the best cyber coverage for financial firms?” or an agent asking about the best flood or trucking markets, AI may highlight just a few trusted sources. If your agency, MGA, or carrier isn’t one of them, you’re invisible in that conversation.
AI Favors Authoritative, Compliant Answers
Clarity and compliance are already your strengths. Well-structured, factual, regulation-conscious content positions your brand as a go-to expert — not just for consumers but also for businesses and brokers researching coverage options.
Early Adopters Will Own the Conversation
Most insurance marketers haven’t optimized for AI visibility yet. Establishing authority now means your name will be the one AI recommends later.
Related: From Google to ChatGPT: Why Insurance SEO Matters More Than Ever in Insurance M&A
3 Best Practices for AI Visibility & SEO
Don’t wait until your competitors surpass you in AI visibility. By taking steps now, you’ll position your brand to be included in all the right conversations.
1. Audit Your Brand Footprint
Look beyond your website. What’s being said about you on review sites, forums, and industry pages?
AI tools use these signals to judge credibility. Clean up old listings, encourage recent reviews, and engage in relevant industry discussions — whether it’s a local homeowner thread or a LinkedIn conversation about commercial property coverage.
2. Create AI-Friendly Content
Develop content designed for how AI systems learn:
- FAQ with short, factual explanations of both personal and commercial insurance questions
- Schema-optimized pages with clear headings (e.g., “How does inland marine insurance work?”)
- Proper citations and disclaimers for compliance
Ask yourself: “Would an AI tool quote this page as an expert answer?”
3. Earn Mentions From Trusted Sources
Guest posts, PR mentions, association listings, and backlinks from credible sites all boost your authority.
Semrush found visibility correlates strongly with off-site brand mentions, not just traditional SEO.
What Not To Forget
- Monitor how often your brand appears in AI answers — tools are emerging to track this.
- Stay compliant and factual — accuracy builds long-term authority.
- Keep content fresh — update pages as products, programs, and regulations evolve.
The Bottom Line on AI Visibility
AI isn’t replacing SEO — it’s reshaping it. Your content, reputation, and visibility across the web now determine whether your brand shows up when AI tools deliver answers.
By the way, “consumers” doesn’t just mean policyholders shopping for home or auto. It means anyone seeking coverage guidance: agents, brokers, business owners, CFOs, and risk managers.
Imagine someone types into ChatGPT, “Who offers the best E&O coverage for agencies?” or “What’s the smartest way to bundle small-business insurance?”
Will your name show up?
If you’re not sure, now is the time to find out. Book a call with Neilson Marketing Services to find out how we’re enhancing AI visibility for our clients.
FAQ About Visibility in AI Platforms
What is AI visibility, and why does it matter for insurance brands?
AI visibility refers to how often and how prominently your brand appears in AI-generated search results and conversations on platforms like ChatGPT and Google’s AI Overviews. For insurance agencies, MGAs, and carriers, strong AI visibility means being recommended as a trusted authority when people ask coverage-related questions — such as “What’s the best business insurance for contractors?” or “Who offers the best cyber coverage for financial firms?” Without optimizing for AI visibility, your brand risks being left out of these critical digital conversations.
What are the most effective strategies for AI visibility enhancement?
The most effective strategies include:
- Auditing your digital footprint to ensure consistent, accurate brand mentions.
- Creating AI-friendly content that answers real insurance questions clearly and compliantly.
- Earning citations from reputable sources, such as industry associations and credible publications.
What are the best practices for AI visibility and SEO?
Best practices include using structured data (schema), writing factual FAQ sections, updating regulatory content frequently, and earning high-quality backlinks. Because AI systems evaluate trust signals beyond keywords — including brand sentiment and authority — your SEO strategy should focus on reputation management as much as on-page optimization.
How can insurance agencies and MGAs create AI-friendly content?
AI-friendly content is clear, factual, and compliant with insurance regulations. Include short, specific explanations to common coverage questions (e.g., “How does inland marine insurance work?”), properly formatted FAQ sections, and transparent disclaimers. These practices not only help AI tools interpret your expertise but also build trust with readers.
How do brand mentions impact visibility in AI platforms?
Semrush’s 2025 AI Visibility Index found that visibility strongly correlates with off-site mentions — not just website SEO. That means industry recognition, PR coverage, and positive reviews all influence how often AI systems recommend your brand. The more credible your presence across digital channels, the higher your AI visibility.
How can insurance marketers improve their AI visibility?
Regularly update website content, maintain compliance accuracy, and engage in public discussions relevant to your markets. Over time, these actions strengthen your visibility signals and increase the likelihood that AI platforms cite your brand as an authoritative source.
